Jim. I did explain why I think it feels like a union situation in the 2, & 3 sentence of my reply.
Pay this organisation $ to supposedly represent me. While at the same time imposing rules for me to abide by weather I agree with it or not. — Andy Laird
That was mainly responding to the ASA example you provided above. I'm not saying its the same thing as a union. But Unions do squeeze out the little guy. You play by their rules and pay them to represent you, or you cant work in an area they control. (That can happen with any association.)
There are other associations that have done the same thing. Not to the extent of the union example, but without the association badge (training certificate) it can be near impossible to get your foot in the door or start working in that field.
I'm using "Unions" generically to try and point out some of the possible negatives of any origination.
I should not assume that others will have the same negative experience with unions, or even see them as a negative in the first place as I do. I'll try my best to keep that in mind in the future. Comprehension or processing the information discussed is is not hard, & I have no trouble with that. Where I struggle is putting my thoughts into words. I'm an upholstery guy not a writer. So I'll do my best to explain why I feel the way I do from now on.
I have a family member who is self employed in an occupation that is far more unknown and obscure than auto upholstery. They are a member of a guild which approx. 4,000 members world wide. This person has the training certificate form the guild, which is the only way to do business with 90% of the retail locations that sell the items being serviced. To get started in that line of work you need that guild badge in order to build up a customer base. The customers ask the retail locations to recommend a technician, and they will only recommend a certified tech. with the badge.
This particular occupation has nothing to do with safety, or complying with state or fed. regulations. It is much more of a skilled artistic line of work. In no way should anyone need to be certified to be in that line of work. But it is now its hard to get your foot in the door without it. This guild started as a way for people in the same line of work to learn from each other, and have some kind of representation with manufacturers. It never started with the idea of trying to keep new people out, but rather to bring them in and help them grow in their profession. Either the people that head the guild got greedy and want it this way (not likely), or the industry just naturally went that direction. To me that is a big turn off.
Eventually the free market will correct it. If there is a need for goods or service, there will always be someone there to fill that need. As long as there is a way to profit form it. That "profit" weather it be $, a sense of obligation, or pride. Supply and demand free from any intervention by a government, price-setting monopoly, or other authority is the key. Maybe there is a need for this service or trade association. I wish you the best in that endeavor... heck you may even convince me.
But for now..
We have a place to exchange ideas learn and grow from one another right here on THR. Thanks to the awesome work of the Mauddi brothers. You are the best!